| Character(s) | Actor |
| Matthew, Villager | Jeff Baer |
| Villager, Goldfish, Islander kid | Gabriella (Gabby) Baker |
| Dr. Dolittle | Lorenz Bilbo |
| Bellowes | Dick Bond |
| Villager, Bear Cub, Fish storm | Gavin Buckmaster |
| Villager, Clown, Mermaid | Kendall Buckmaster |
| Jip-Jip | Kylie Buckmaster |
| Tommy | Shayn Carmichael-Kohn |
| Villager, Lion Tamer | James Carmichael-Kohn |
| Villager, Goldfish, Bearded lady, Jellyfish | Rylee Comstock |
| Villager, Acrobat, Flamingo | Jenna Cook |
| Villager, Island | Joshua Core |
| Shadow | Lucy Elgin |
| Villager, Blossom, Island elephant | Dennis Fisher |
| Villager, Lion cub, Islander kid | Logan Fisher |
| Shadow | Elly Gottsch |
| Villager, Strongman, Islander | Shawn Hanowell |
| Villager, Sheila the Fox, Islander | Jillian Hansen |
| Polynesia | Molly Hare |
| Villager, Clown , Fish storm | Colin Harrison |
| Chee-Chee | Hannah Hiers |
| Villager, Mildred (cow), Unicorn Island | Janeen Hilbrink |
| Town Crier, Villager, Dragon island | Bev Icalia |
| Dymm-Witt, Bear, Dodo, Bird islander | Mike Jaffe |
| Villager, Tiger, Jellyfish storm | Sara Jaffe |
| Villager, Bird | Kimberly Jones |
| Villager, Islander kid | Amanda Lambert |
| Shadow | Kenneth Leja |
| Villager, Islander | Dawn Magee |
| Villager, Dancer, Islander | Erica Matsuda |
| Rufus the dog, Villager, Island kid | Dylan Milburn |
| Villager, Lion, Straight Arrow | Patrick Moser |
| Shadow | Hailey Nelson |
| Villager, Gertie, Elephant island | Fawnia Oblack |
| Kitten | Emmalee Rae |
| Villager, Toggle, Islander | David Reavis |
| Gub-Gub | Arella Rodriguez |
| Kitten | Gillian Rodriguez |
| Court Clerk/Bailiff, Policeman | Ed Stiner |
| Shadow | Kristine Thomas |
| Villager, Giraffe, Islander | Macey Trussell |
| Kitten | Lindsey Tudela |
| Dab-Dab, Villager, Islander, Villager | Soren Urban |
| Villager, Sophie the Seal, Octopus | Marah Walsh |
| Villager, Islander | Toby Walsh |
| Shadow | Allison Watkins |
| Emma | Tracy Webber |
